A friend of mine yesterday asked me why we chop off our daughters' clitories. I struggled with some of the answers on the defensive side including health, moral values, and cultural pride. At the end my answers were not convincing. So I just shook my head and said, many of us don't do it any more. So I'm bringing the question katika ukumbi huu wa kikuyu dot kom. WHY DO WE REALLY CHOP OFF OUR GIRLS' CLITORIES? PROS & CONS PLEASE.
I once knew a Nyeri lady, well educated, or rather, over educated, social anthropologist and she persisted that FGM was NOT a Kikuyu tradition. Wierd, her answer I mean, but on other hand, she was not always the brightest...
I respect traditions and cultural traditional values but luckely FGM has no more part to play anymore, as Papa Daad, just explained.
Hyrax Hill Mafia
Posts: 611 | Location: Stockholm | Registered: 28 January 2007
Papa Daad, Ignoring the Mukurweini wa Nyagathanga myth, I have always hypothesized that the Kikuyus are an amalgamation of different ethnic groupings. That is why they are very good at aping others. In fact, I think that the main reason behind the invention of Gikuyu and nine daughters was to create a sense of ethnic cohesion because of their insecurity.
Emotions are the greatest enemy of rational arguments
Posts: 3163 | Location: Neither here nor there | Registered: 03 May 2005
Both male genital mutilation (MGM) and female genital mutilation (FGM) are kikuyu cultural traditional values. They were practices to mark passing to age from childhood to adulthood. Currently, MGM is still practiced almost 100%, but FGM has declined with time. However, none of this two practices have are done the way they used to be done before cultural deterioration that resulted from colonization.
Paul,
From traditional point of view, both MGM and FGM had cultural and social values. However, the main value of these practices was embedded on the training the youngsters went though during initiation. These values are no longer embedded in these practices. This has resulted into have them just as a ritual which is useless. If there is nothing that the youngsters learn from the practice, then they are of no values except pride.
Those on-the-know argues that in a polygamous society like the traditional kikuyu society, FGM was important in taming the women. They argue that it reduces female sexual desire. In such a society one man can marry several wives without denying any of them their congenial rights. However, in the current social set up, them this practices has no part to play.
Paapa Daad;
I beg to differ with you a bit in regards to what you are calling MGM-Male genital mutilation. I think thats not the correct term as Mutilatition is an equivalent word to maiming which is an act or physical injury that degrades the appearance or function of the (human) body, usually without causing death. For the male body part that undergoes this rite...the above description doesnt apply; hence the reason the practice is not called MGM and its better referred to circumcision and where the ladies are concerned its FGM because it causes more harm than good.
That my way of understanding it-but I stand to be corrected.
Posts: 1581 | Location: Kiamatawa | Registered: 14 March 2007
Circumcisions are normally carried out without anaesthetic, and can result in infection – as well as severe pain during urination, menstruation, sexual intercourse and childbirth. Girls who undergo the procedure have also been known to die from excessive bleeding and infection.
Legal Status: There are no laws making FGM/FGC illegal in Kenya. There are provisions in the Penal Code pertaining to "Offenses Against Person and Health" that might be applicable. However, there have been no arrests for FGM/FGC on the basis of these provisions. In November 1996, Parliament defeated a motion to make this practice illegal. In 1982 and 1989, President Moi issued Presidential decrees banning the practice.
The government prohibits the practice in government-controlled hospitals and clinics. In 1982, the Director of Medical Services instructed all hospitals to stop the practice, stating that he would prosecute medical professionals performing FGM/FGC under the Medical Practitioners and Dentists Act and the Nurses, Midwives and Health Visitors Act.
One where i come from its a myth and people believe it enhances fertility and promotes child survivor,i dont know how this can be proofed,bt thinks it holds sm water.
Two its because of hygiene and aesthetic reasons,external female genitalia are considered dirty and unsightly and are to be removed to promote hygiene and provide aesthetic appeal.
PLease note this is according to where i come from and i think the cons of this practice out weighs the prosThis message has been edited. Last edited by: wangu wa makeri,
It is fruitless to attempt to indoctrinate a superannuated canine with innovative maneuvers.
Ngaii kai umite kuu,ask yourself, would you do tht to your daughter or your siz?nindamaka
Now we are thomud shesh,i meant long time ago and most of you people were not born,presently we have buried the practice,bt that wat they were saying at that time.You know our home borders mukurwe wa nyagathanga,and we used even to hang around wen we had such occasion.
Hope ave cleared the air shesh
It is fruitless to attempt to indoctrinate a superannuated canine with innovative maneuvers.
Utakanyuiriire ndoi ke rita. Ask most men and they will tell you it is a total-total mutilation. There is total physical injury of the body. Do you dare talk about degradation of function? The MGM is known to reduce male sexual arousal and libido. isn’t this degrading a very important function.